oyster - St. Paul Fish Company

Category: oysterOctober 4, 2018

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

St. Paul Fish Company

4.4

Based on 1395 Reviews

Doobee C.

2024-09-22 08:59:35

I had the pan seared Mahi Mahi ! Extremely delicious My wife had the lobster sandwich ! The best by far Definitely coming back and try all their...

Cindy L.

2024-09-12 15:56:37

Crab Cake 4 real blue crab, medium flavorful New England Clam Chowder 2 watery Lobster Roll 3 cold shredded lobster salad, no chunks Blackened Chilean Sea...

Lori L.

2024-09-10 16:34:33

If I could write a review for the outdoor Tiki bar it would be a billion stars because it's so awesome in the winter to feel like you are in the tropics....

Daviyion J.

2024-09-09 19:51:32

Checked out this place on a recommendation from someone at the airport as I was just visiting Milwaukee for business and I gotta say I was not a fan of this...

Jen W.

2024-09-01 10:07:10

Great food in a cool market. I was nervous at first because I thought I had to hover and grab a table. It was a little chaotic, but I finally focused on...

Tracey M.

2024-08-31 18:06:12

In May my husband and I drove out to Milwaukee to take my his brother out for his birthday. When we got to this place, which we visited twice previously, we...

Suzanne B.

2024-08-26 14:41:33

Visited again on Sunday, 08 25/2024 Husband had a Shrimp Po'Boy. It was loaded with shrimp, dressed up with lettuce tomato, and aioli sauce. Maybe something...

Izzy L.

2024-08-02 06:20:29

St. Paul Fish Company in the Historic Third Ward of Milwaukee is hands down the best spot for seafood and oysters in MKE. The staff is incredibly friendly...

samantha s.

2024-07-27 17:12:26

Mussels and cod we're fresh and tasty. Service was fast and friendly. We were able to get seated right away.

Kathy D.

2024-07-14 19:13:24

I Had this place on my list for our overnight visit in Milwaukee. I called to see if they were busy because it was close to 7 pm. We paid to park across the...

Justine H.

2024-06-20 13:05:15

Came here as a random eenie-meenie when plans to go to a different restaurant fell through. They have daily specials after 4pm and we came on a Tuesday so...

Joshua P.

2024-06-03 13:59:42

The lobster roll was terrible. I'm from the east-coast, so expectations were already low, but it was terrible. One of the workers assured me it was "all...

Greg W.

2024-05-30 10:36:49

Had the pleasure of staying in the Third Ward a few blocks from the Public Market so had to check it out. While walking around the "daily specials" board at...

Faith B.

2024-05-05 14:30:49

I had lunch with a friend here recently during the week, but not quite at lunch time. This seems to be the secret to getting a table without an issue as...

Mike H.

2024-05-04 15:38:02

I was staying at a hotel in the 3rd Ward and looking for an easy dinner place. The public market had a lot of variety so I walked through. St. Paul Fish...

Stephen C.

2024-05-01 08:30:01

Our dining choice for lunch in Milwaukee it's located in the 3rd Ward Public Market. Unique setting in an old warehouse filled with many shops and dining...

Colter H.

2024-03-28 15:43:43

Amazing across the board. For not being on the ocean, this is some of the best seafood you'll find, full stop. Sit at the bar, grab something cold, and...

Ken L.

2024-03-20 17:44:36

Best stop in Milwaukee for fresh seafood! The service is great seated at a table or at the bar. They have a the best and fastest guy in the business busting...

Seymore I.

2024-03-13 14:43:53

Delicious, the finest fish purveyor in Milwaukee, bar none....I am a return, satisfied customer over years . 5 star

Joshua S.

2024-03-10 07:22:13

Really good food. Great service. This place is my favorite when visiting Milwaukee. Has a really good vibe.

Nisheet G.

2024-03-06 17:33:34

While visiting Milwaukee, I came across the Public Market and decided to pop-in and came across St Paul Fish Company. Here are my ratings: Quality of food:...

Amber L.

2024-01-18 07:52:00

I've heard good things about their fish fry, it seems to be a common Wisconsinite mission to find the best! If you've been to the Milwaukee Public Market,...

Jenny C.

2023-12-05 13:12:41

I highly recommend eating here when visiting the Milwaukee public market! It's in the corner of the market with seating next to the restaurant and open...

Troy D.

2023-09-22 12:38:33

Cruisin thru the public market, sportin your Harley Davidson and/or Brewers gear and looking for some good eats? Well you wouldn't be alone because that's...

George L.

2023-09-17 10:37:26

I ordered the food to my hotel, unfortunately they didn't send me the oysters I ordered which was a huge letdown because I'd already paid through Uber eats,...

Lisa T.

2023-08-28 06:48:04

We came right when they opened on a weekend and got a table right away. Tables filled up very quickly. Our order was taken but the last to come...

Junior R.

2023-08-20 15:07:54

Service take a while, waiters not on point and food is average. Drinks are good and so is the ambient

Laurie F.

2023-08-20 09:45:29

Great food every time I visit Service is also outstanding. Quick, accurate orders and always with a smile

Len L.

2023-08-14 12:57:05

Upon entering the Public Market, it was overwhelming to see so many people and so many vendors selling their food to you to miss that I needed to register...

Sydney W.

2023-08-14 06:26:43

This place had such amazing food and it was also really affordable! We absolutely loved our food and the service was great too. Every food item comes out of...

Allen W.

2023-08-07 14:35:30

Awesome place awesome food I would highly recommend their tacos and their crabcakes. It is a place that you will enjoy and you will find you want to come back

John J.

2023-07-16 19:36:58

Nestled in the opening of the Public Market, St. Paul's has a small dining area. It's small but the tables are spaced well. Service by Carolyn was...

Zhan Wen L.

2023-06-25 12:36:01

St Paul is my favorite go-to spot for a quick day trip from Chicago and I love to take my friends here . It is located inside the Milwaukee Public Market....

Trinh T.

2023-06-24 06:02:24

St Paul Fish Company is a market + restaurant located inside the Milwaukee Public Market in Downtown Milwaukee. It's a fresh, busy, exciting, and a must...

Michelle F.

2023-06-18 11:49:39

St. Paul's is the best place for a fun dinner experience. We always end up gravitating here for dinner even though we tell ourselves we'll try other places....

Maggie B.

2023-06-05 09:51:52

This is my go-to spot in Milwaukee. I always know the food is going to be fresh and delicious. I get the fish dinners, huge portions for the price!! I...

Barb R.

2023-05-17 16:30:09

Love Love Love the fried oyster basket. I often order that just for myself off the appetizer list for my meal. Always a treat!!!!

chelsea j.

2023-05-13 20:52:27

Lobster roll is my favorite and the pina colada. They also have really good service!!

Masha V.

2023-05-13 12:52:52

Located inside the Milwaukee Public Market, this adorable fish market is a must! The seafood is so fresh and delicious, I've never had anything bad here...

Emma P.

2023-04-27 08:11:40

Amazing food and great location. I will make the trip into the city just to get their shrimp po boy. Very fresh seafood and delicious soups. Service can...

Kimiko L.

2023-04-26 15:35:55

Counter top service quick and on point. Their style of lobster roll is not my favorite- but that doesn't take away that the bread is done well, nice and...

Roganne R.

2023-04-18 17:29:44

Stopped in on the nite prior to our Vaca. Matt-O was our bartender. We love coming here. PJ is who we normally see. Matt-O was awesome! Helpful, nice and...

Katrina B.

2023-03-27 23:54:03

Amazing lobster rolls and seafood for purchase. The I Love you place I go for my lobster rolls and my daughter loves this spot

Molly D.

2023-03-24 08:06:43

Soooo- oyster Thursday's are becoming a weekly thing now. How have I never known St. Paul's Fish Company in the Public Market does 1$ oysters on Thursday?!...

Ann H.

2023-03-23 15:10:35

We don't get to come to the Milwaukee Public Market as often as we'd like, but when we do (and the wait isn't too long) we eat at the St Paul Fish...

Quinn H.

2023-02-26 18:24:18

Went to St. Paul fish company in Mequon! My friends and I have passed through the public market admiring the lobster roll- it was about time we tried it...

Tony S.

2023-02-23 11:28:19

Great fish Great food Great people! A wonderful bar and a nice location devoid of low life's! 5 tunas!

Masha V.

2023-02-19 05:32:54

I'm obsessed with this place! Laid back atmosphere, great service and excellent seafood. What more can you ask for? I got the clam chowder, blue point...

Erin P.

2023-01-25 16:30:11

The food at this location is always good and the staff makes an amazing margarita. They were clearly training a new bartender who was doing his best given...

Steve B.

2023-01-14 15:57:54

We stopped here for lunch. We have been wanting to try this restaurant for a while. They have another location in Mequon, but who really wants to go to...

Meagan C.

2023-01-01 16:04:50

Amazing. The Calamari Steak was delicious, one of the best things I've ever eaten. The shrimp were gigantic and so great! The service was perfect! This...

Tony T.

2023-01-01 01:46:07

We accidentally ended up at milwaukee's public market and wow what a excitement of having small restaurants and a lot of chess and wine spot here but we got...

Jill O.

2022-12-29 17:43:35

This place was rocking when we stopped by! We were pleasantly surprised when the wait time was only 15 minutes and we were able to get a table. The...

Bri B.

2022-12-15 13:13:37

Atmosphere: Super busy every time I've been here. Outdoor tikki seating in the warmer season of the year. You can buy fresh seafood to go so you can cook it...

Joanne Y.

2022-11-29 09:31:29

I was visiting my sister and her boyfriend in Milwaukee and we decided to come to St Paul's for lunch. You need to stop by the counter to get seated (and...

Matthew B.

2022-11-26 05:28:25

I was so hungry I had to dive right in. This isn't the best lobster roll I've ever had, but man it did not disappoint! There have been places that are...

Mitch L.

2022-11-06 18:03:46

Food - the salmon crack is the off the charts. It's a must. The New England clam chowder is great. The lobster on the stick is cooked perfectly. Service -...

M L.

2022-10-30 13:07:23

Alright, I grew up near the ocean, but on the left coast, so I'm a snob when it comes to fresh seafood (It doesn't help when I have best friends who are...

Shanel S.

2022-10-28 08:19:56

Went to a show at Fiserc Forum and wanted to have dinner at a spot nearby. This place was definitely a great spot being in the Milwaukee Public Market. The...

Keala P.

2022-10-25 17:47:36

Super amazing. Crazy quick and fabulous service. The fired oysters and the oysters Rockefeller was unbelievable. Highly recommended. I really wish I was...

O O.

2022-10-15 14:30:04

4.5 stars! Visiting from the Bay Area, nice visit - food here is great! Especially the bloody Mary, it's like a meal by itself. Complete with lobster...

Julie T.

2022-09-27 07:42:38

Still dreaming about this lobster roll. It's one the best I ever had. Wish we have something closer to Chicago to fulfill my lobster roll needs. That just...

Mike T.

2022-09-21 07:37:02

Day 1 - Ate in the dinning room and was I blown away how great the food was. Day 2 - Sat at the outside bar for lunch, the fish fry (lake perch and...

Andrew J.

2022-08-22 21:52:12

Had a very good meal here that I thought was delicious. We split the New England King Crab Boil which included 1lb of crab meat, red potatoes and corn....

Steve B.

2022-08-18 12:47:46

My wife and I have visited St. Paul's Fish Market more than a dozen times. We have tried almost every seafood on their menu and amazingly each dish was...

George G.

2022-08-18 11:03:38

grouper and fries OMG OMG OMG huge piece breaded, took the breading off and it was great tasting.

Roger T.

2022-08-11 17:12:44

Very fun scene at the outside bar along the street. Can be a little hectic getting a seat as it's first come first serve...but work with bar tenders....

Jill M.

2022-08-02 09:26:31

First time eating here & will not be the last! Took a quick weekend trip out to Milwaukee back in December, we came across this place and decided to check...

Michael B.

2022-07-28 15:00:32

Located in the public market. Eat at the bar, walk up to go, or eat at the dine in tables. Fresh Seafood and full drink menu. Large portions at a...

Ken H.

2022-07-22 19:38:47

fresh seafood, friendly service and they do cook to order. However a few things that left a bit to be desired. Oysters (yes its my fault to order at wrong...

Patti L.

2022-07-09 13:14:37

Fresh and delicious. Friends come here every time they come to Milwaukee. It is located in a public market in which there are food stalls that sell spices,...

Steven N.

2022-06-26 06:46:19

Yes, the hype is real! This place is really popular and has a lot going for it. There is limited seating in the their little dining area affiliated with the...

Nelson O.

2022-06-22 18:16:33

Before I begin this review, let me say that I love St Paul's food and have been going here for years. With that said, on June 22, 2022, I had a very...

Jeff K.

2022-06-22 10:50:28

I've yet to have a negative experience here. What to expect: no-frills fresh as hell, affordable as hell, and delicious as hell seafood and Schlitz. Did I...

Lara E.

2022-06-18 16:26:23

This restaurant was recommended by a few of my friends so me & my fiancé had to check it out especially since we love seafood. The restaurant is inside of...

Anna P.

2022-06-10 21:06:21

Delicious food and great service. Waiter was awesome about giving good suggestions. What more could you ask for?

Ryu ..

2022-06-09 09:48:30

i've never been here before but im giving it a 5 star anyways thats all i wanted to say

Christopher A.

2022-06-07 19:38:36

Stopped by on a Saturday and it was busy. Decided to eat at the restaurant and it was a 20 or so min wait. Check in at the counter and they give you one of...

Lisa L.

2022-06-04 18:17:57

First of all, it's incredibly loud there. Took a while to order and get it right. The lobster roll had insane amount of mayo in it, the mayo covered up...

Arturo M.

2022-05-19 15:41:08

Saw this spot on Food Network and it made my mouth water just watching over the TV. Now I found myself in Milwaukee so I knew I had to try it out for...

Jan A.

2022-03-11 13:05:22

Very accommodating. I often order the Lobster roll deconstructed so the Brioche, is not squishy and wet by the time I get it home. It is always delicious.

Lauren L.

2022-02-24 19:36:49

I visit here everytime I come to Milwaukee. I can always rely on St. Paul to give us fresh, tasty oysters. They are also very reasonably priced. I have also...

Abdullah A.

2022-02-05 21:10:02

Had dinner here with friends before a Bucks game. St. Paul fish company is a fish monger in the Milwaukee Public Market with a small dining area. It got...

Sharon M. T.

2022-01-07 20:14:33

This place is exceptional. We happened to stumble upon this place walking past and ended up staying the entire day! The waitstaff was very accommodating....

Jeff C.

2022-01-05 16:34:07

Best lobstah roll in the Midwest and some damn good oysters too! I have been here a few times now and every time I am so happy to experience a solid lobster...

Rance Z.

2021-12-02 14:09:20

So I was a bit skeptical I'd have phenomenal seafood in Wisconsin. I was proven dead wrong. I had some oysters on the half shell, a clam bake, and then a...

Atul S.

2021-11-25 14:35:56

The food was very good here. I took fried fish (forgot the name of the fish) but it tasted very good. Also, they are overloaded with fries on the side. For...

Gerry T.

2021-09-23 05:14:06

When you think of Milwaukee, the things that come to mind are beer, cheese, brats, the Brewers and Harley Davidson, but one doesn't think of Lobsta rolls....

Doug W.

2021-08-03 05:46:26

I love this restaurant. We recently visited Milwaukee for the weekend and went twice to the Public Market. We weren't very hungry on our first visit but...

Cameron M.

2021-07-31 08:27:02

For being a fish place, some of the worst fish I've ever had at a restaurant. The drinks were also poorly made and the only thing saving this from being a...

Jose C.

2021-07-27 19:44:11

I had the Lobster Roll and a bowl of the shrimp and sausage soup. Both were delicious, highly recommend!

Stan W.

2021-07-23 18:53:22

I had blackened halibut wife had grilled salmon both with garden veggies. Served piping hot and fresh. Plan on returning soon.

Nina H.

2021-07-19 18:33:58

You can't beat a lobster roll for $18.00. That's how much I paid for my lobster roll with fries and slaw at St. Paul Fish. Hearty and delicious served Maine...

Phil Y.

2021-07-17 22:37:12

Family vacation 2021...bringing the California variant of COVID-19 to your city. The St. Paul Fish Company was one of the busiest vendors at the Milwaukee...

Daniela B.

2021-06-25 06:56:18

Dinner with a friend at SPFC. It was her first time trying it and my second one. This restaurant was very busy, and noisy as everything starts to pick...

Evangeline I.

2021-06-24 19:07:58

Recently went here again when I was in town to watch the Bucks play. Still as good as I remembered it. They had their 1/2 off special for oysters, so we...

Christina T.

2021-05-13 22:48:26

Wow!!! Just wow!!! I was definitely impressed with this spot!! I went to Milwaukee randomly for a day and after walking around, I decided to try this place...

Jessica J.

2021-05-10 08:30:59

Good ol' St. Paul's! This place really does deserve all the love they get on Yelp. We were gifted a Public Market gift card and our first thought was to...

Abby O.

2021-04-29 10:33:07

I cannot say enough good things about this spot. Super cool location right in the market, reasonable prices and FANTASTIC service. Our server, Patrick, went...

Charmaine D.

2021-04-01 17:10:17

Called ahead to place an order for pickup. They said it would be ready between 5-10 min. Picked it up, brought it back to the hotel room, spread out the...

Craig A.

2021-03-22 14:17:51

Love this place to death, highly recommend the lobster roll, best you'll get in Wisconsin for sure. Staff is amazing, specifically JJ who is usually behind...

Dmitriy M.

2021-03-13 22:24:01

My favorite place in Milwaukee! fresh seafood, great quality and simplicity make this place inviting. Once, while ordering takeout oysters, I came across...

PJ C.

2021-01-01 14:22:12

I know this wasn't the first time I have eaten here when in Milwaukee's Third Ward so it was time for a review. We stopped in on a week day in mid-December...

Viv P.

2020-12-22 21:24:09

I just realized that I'm updating more reviews than actually making new ones... but covid does make it harder to try new places. And St. Paul's definitely...

Jenny B.

2020-12-02 07:28:38

St. Paul's is incredible! I would give them more than 5 stars if I could. Their fish always tastes fresh and their chowder is to die for! I haven't been...

Ryan P.

2020-11-30 18:28:21

My two most memorable visits took place before the pandemic, but since this small business had a lot of flare and I want to help make sure they stick around...

Robert S.

2020-11-21 21:13:35

Cliché alert!! If I could give them 10 stars I would! Ok. Now let's get into the nitty gritty. I drove my son's posessions across the country to Chicago...

Pearl N.

2020-10-14 12:40:56

Service: best! Shoutout to gentleman at the bar(both outside and inside) an old man, a bigger man serve out side, 2 skinnier man inside, the sweet Latino...

Kyle D.

2020-10-12 11:24:53

Overall: Hands down one of the best lobster rolls we've ever had! The good: You'd think you were on the East Coast with how amazing their lobster roll is...

Heide P.

2020-10-07 04:54:33

Saint Paul fish company does a great job with social distancing. It was the first and only restaurant we return to to eat inside at this point. The fish is...

Winnie C.

2020-10-04 14:09:47

The food stand is located inside the Milwaukee Public Market. They currently have their indoor seatings open. I would recommend taking your food to the...

C. S.

2020-09-23 16:34:39

Awesomely delicious! You must come and try anything on their menu. So good! Try their Ginormous lobster roll or there are some fish dinners. And I must not...

Ari W.

2020-09-15 07:34:13

A must go when in Milwaukee. The market itself is stacked with options but I never usually make it past the fish market which is located right next to the...

Greg F.

2020-09-02 19:11:31

Pretty fun place!! With some great fresh seafood! Stopped in here for a quick bite after landing for business. It was so good I came back for lunch on my...

Insiya T.

2020-08-27 08:17:07

Was visiting public market area and thought I'd check this place out. Seriously the best lobsters rolls I've ever had, lots of good juicy pieces, the roll...

Kendra L.

2020-05-16 19:31:53

I am dreaming of the day we can go back to St. Paul Fish Company and enjoy the lobster, the oysters, the atmosphere! The line to get a table is...

Kaden C.

2020-05-10 20:28:00

Located inside the Milwaukee Public Market, St Paul's deserves recognition on its own. SPFC is the best fish you can find in Milwaukee for a great price!...

Brian M.

2020-03-13 20:27:12

I enjoy the Milwaukee Market and all the different dining options that come along with it. I've walked by St. Paul Fish Company a number of times and often...

Carla M.

2020-03-11 07:07:10

Delicious .. hubs and I were in town for a quick weekend trip in the area and stopped in the historic third ward district. The area itself is really neat. I...

Amy Z.

2020-03-01 19:27:38

The fish n chips (Schlitz Battered Cod Fry) is awesome at only $12! Four generous pieces of cod thinly battered and fried to perfection. I highly recommend...

Stephanie H.

2019-01-22 07:22:47

St. Paul Fishing Company is a fun and casual seafood place! I love coming here and sitting out at the Tiki bar in the summer. It's a fun place to hang out...

Lauren R.

2019-01-21 08:52:55

Went for the ice bar, had no seafood, but had a FANTASTIC time! Ice bars in the 3rd Ward started and you CANNOT miss St. Paul Fish Co. a main plus is...

Valerie J.

2019-01-09 22:37:22

This place is just the best. I have taken my parents and my in-laws here b/c it really is just an amazing, happy place that always delivers! Great service...