Based on 132 Reviews
Perhaps it was a matter of just an off day as we have had better experiences here but nothing seemed to go well on this visit. Although the New England...
The food, prices and service here are really good. I had the lobster roll and Amy had the crab roll. Wow! Can't say enough about both of those. The lobster...
Great food, great staff. Can't go wrong with a King Crab Boil or Seafood boil, or some fresh fish they have in retail like their amazing Chilean Sea Bass or...
Here's the thing... it can be tricky getting good seafood in Wisconsin; and St. Paul's nails it. The local fish that most of us are used to are good, the...
I've been wanting to try this place for quite a while. My mother and I decided to grab a late afternoon lunch here on a Saturday afternoon. The restaurant...
Excellent food.. very trendy restaurant with a bar, as well as a seafood market... great service and friendly servers... it was very busy and our food...
We were pleased with everything from the service to the food. Our server Morgan was very friendly and attentive. Not easy to find anymore as restaurants...
Usually like this place. But today I made a reservation due an outdoor table for dinner. Did it at 7AM. We get there and were told that they don't have an...
Highly recommend St. Paul if you're in the mood for fish! They have an amazing fish fry, great fish tacos, and even a great ceviche. They are known for...
Delightful crew, great seafood, comfortable atmosphere and just an all around good place to go!!!
My 2nd favorite seafood restaurant! Fist is Harbor House which is more expensive. Love this place. Great lobster roll and Bloody Mary! Every thing is...
Seems like they don't know how to make lobster rolls. Their lobster rolls had no taste at all, just plain and boring. Rolls were dry and lobsters had...
Really really neat place. Probably one of the best fish fries I've ever had. Plenty of fish. I chose veggies instead of chips or fries. Would have liked...
We were so happy to order this delicious Perch Fry with a very generous serving! First course was wonderful clam chowder. Delish! Our server Emily was...
Great reasonably priced seafood. Fast lunch service. Very disappointed that they now only serve the crab rolls at the Milwaukee location.
I am really looking forward to a return here. I have a heard a lot about the Lobster Rolls. They were delicious and lived up to the hype. The food deserves...
Amazing seafood. I had a king crab 1lb boil for 27.99!!! It was delicious! Also had the crab cakes, calamari and a lobster roll. I loved it all. The best...
Had 6:30 reservations on a Friday night and was seated promptly, even with the restaurant being at capacity. Drink menu was fun, yet compact, and the...
My wife and I would travel from Mequon to Milwaukee Public Market just to eat lunch at St. Paul's Fish Company on Water Street for many years. I always...
Had a delicious experience for my first time visiting the Mequon location. I arrived just in time for Happy Hour! I sat at the bar which had great dividers...
I had no idea we had something like this locally. From the moment you walk in you feel like you're on the coast. The fresh market is to die for. From the...
The downtown location has been a long time bookmark for the lobster roll and a cup of clam chowder but I didn't want to deal with the parking hassles of...
Fantastic! You cannot go wrong with ANYTHING on the menu. My Go-to favorites are the lobster roll, any of the grilled fish dinners, and the crab cake...
Erin was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu and establishment. We absolutely destroyed the "Milwaukee Fish Fry". Very generous portion sizes...
Can someone please explain to me why it took so long for me to finally try this place out??????? I knew I had to come here when a family friend from Boston...
Great food, excellent prices and friendly professional service. If you don't give this place 5 stars you need to leave Wisconsin.
Two words: catfish fry. Two more words. Walleye fry. Everything I've tried has been delicious. I only wish they had non-waiter indoor seating like they do...
Great Happy Hour prices, patio is open. King Crab Legs were sweet, and delicious. The one pound happy hour serving was as good as the evening dinner, for...
St. Paul Fish is one of our favorite places to eat in Chicago or Milwaukee. Love eating in the bar at happy hour. Service is outstanding and bartenders and...
Compared to the downtown location, this is by far a lot more friendlier and more welcoming location. My friends and i continue to return about once a week...
We had such a wonderful dinner at St. Pauls on a Saturday evening. The restaurant/bar was hopping! We were greeted and told there would be a half hour...